Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

The effects of unhealthy living – cost of the couch

The following Healthcare Newsletter was issued by ACA Employee Benefits – 2019

Unhealthy lifestyles are clearly linked to serious long-term health problems as well as significant short term wellness impairment. The answer to this risk is behaviour change but it is not happening.

In the South African Financial Services sector some 55% of the population is overweight, 60% do not exercise, 20% smoke, 20% report serious stress problems…the list goes on and paints an alarming picture1 : few live well and few are well. The most worrying issues are the classic ones of being overweight and lack of exercise.

Weight

Body Mass Index (BMI) is a simple formula (weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared) that describes how round (or overweight) a person is, independent of gender or age.

BMI classifies people as:

  • Underweight (BMI <18.5)
  • Healthy weight (BMI 18.5-24.9)
  • Overweight (BMI 25.0 to 29.9)
  • Obese (BMI 30+)

Despite being imperfect (e.g. it does some injustice to the very muscular, the pregnant, and young children) BMI has been repeatedly shown to be accurate for the vast majority of people, reliable, and practical. BMI remains the universal standard.

Repeated reputable peer-reviewed research has demonstrated that being overweight increases the risk of developing cardiovascular disease (mainly heart attack and stroke), diabetes, osteoarthritis, many cancers (including breast, prostate, and colon), and psychological issues linked to poor self-esteem and stigmatisation (the notion of the “jolly fat person” is a cruel myth).

There has been some debate around the question of “borderline overweight” and at just what level health concerns begin. Most experts now agree that there are real health risks for all people who have a BMI over 25, albeit that the risks increase as the BMI does – a logical-enough view recently substantiated in a huge 2015 study of 65m+ people across 125 countries and 25 years2.

Active living

The human being is intended to live actively. And did so, until the time of the industrial revolution. It is no longer so, with almost half of us now living sedentary lives. The active living recommendations most widely used are:

  1. EXERCISE: 120-150 minutes of moderate deliberate exercise (sweaty short-of-breath exercise) per week
  2. ACTIVITY: 30 minutes of (non-sweaty, gentle activity) OR 10 000 steps a day
  3. SITTING: Less than 5 hours of sitting per day

All three are important. Each confers health and risk benefits of its own - it seems that each is an independent risk factor and so, for example, even very fit athletes have some health risk if they sit all day at work. The research on sitting is relatively new but it seems possible that sitting may be the most important risk factor of all3 (watch this area for more developments in the coming years).

The impact of sedentary living includes an increased risk of developing cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and osteoporosis and many cancers (including breast and colon), depression and anxiety.

Summary of the long-term impact of unhealthy living

RISK OVERWEIGHT SEDENTARY
Cardiovascular Disease
Diabetes
Osteoarthritis  
Osteoporosis  
Cancers (various)
Psychological Issues
Reduced Lifespan

The short term?

Besides the serious long-term effects of couch-potato living there are also profound short-term effects. It is clear that overweight and sedentary living are associated with low energy levels, concentration problems, reduced productivity, lower mood, and sleep problems. It’s as if the way we feel is a result of our lifestyles, and that’s because it is!

The paradox

Very little of this is new or unheard of. These are well-known facts for the most part, certainly among educated populations. And yet the prevalence of overweight has doubled since 1980 (in the “western” world)2 with similarly alarming declines in exercise and activity4. The truth is that a great many people are ignoring what they know is good (and bad) for them. Or at least not doing anything about it. This is sometimes called the “wellness paradox” and is a definitive challenge for individuals, healthcare professionals, behaviourists, employers, governments and society in general. Despite huge investments, much advertising, a massive industry, and much concern, there is little evidence of real change.

How to change?

Change is hard. Certainly it is hard to achieve in the area of lifestyle behaviours. What works? What has become fairly clear is that simply presenting information to people does not work (largely because people already know what you’re telling them in the google-age). Even presenting personalised information (typically as health risk assessment reports) has shown disappointing results as regards behaviour change. So the classical wellness programmes based on information and health risk assessment have under-performed – they do raise awareness and create a valuable platform but on their own, do not deliver the required behaviour change.

It is fairly clear that the issue is a deep and complex behavioural one - it’s psychological & emotional more than anything else and as long as this is ignored or under-emphasised, as has largely been the case to date, results will be disappointing. Some principles are emerging:

  • Tell the truth. Quick fixes, miracle cures, painless diets and no-sweat exercise plans are all nonsense. Cruel nonsense at that, usually aimed to generating profits. We disrespect ourselves if we believe these false promises.
  • Make it easy – the healthy choice should be the easy choice. This is about making showers and healthy menus available at work, putting your exercise bicycle in front of your TV rather than in the garage, etc.
  • Respect and empower – people want to be acknowledged and supported, not instructed or commanded. Every person is the expert on themselves, always. This is about the tone and approach used in all communications and programmes.
  • Make it the norm – peer-pressure and social norms are hugely powerful influencers. Leading from the top/front, doing it together, being an active family, and creating ongoing focus on wellness are all effective approaches.
  • Make it fun – so-called “gamification” (a horrid word if ever there was) seems to work. This includes competitive elements and fun interactivity.
  • Recognise – noticing and applauding healthy behaviours is motivating for the individuals and for the broader audience. Celebrate successes, especially involving those with “typical” challenges - the story of the first-time 10km walker is probably more meaningful than the one about the runner completing her 20th marathon.
  • Incentivise – a controversial one, with many experts suggesting that material incentives “cheapen” what should be an inherent motivation and yet “real world” programmes often benefit from material incentives.

These principles can be applied individually, with others, within a company or in broader society-wide strategies. They do improve the odds of creating sustained change although in truth there is much still to learn. You can look at your personal, family, company or medical scheme approach and test it against these principles if you’d like to optimise results.

We really DO need to eat-less-eat-better-move-more-sit-less. We also need to be brutally and totally honest about why we do not.

AUTHOR
Dr Colin Burns
Health & Wellness Consultant
Sanlam Health
REFERENCES
1. Sanlam Health Data (unpublished)
2. Health Effects of Overweight and Obesity in 195 Countries over 25 Years; The GBD 2015 Obesity Collaborators; N Engl J Med 2017; 377:13-27July 6, 2017DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1614362
3. Too much sitting linked to heart disease, diabetes, premature death; Julie Corliss; Posted January 22, 2015, 10:44 am; Julie Corliss, Executive Editor, Harvard Heart Letter
4. Sedentary Behaviors and Youth: Current Trends and the Impact on Health; January 2014; Author: Deborah W. Lou, PhD, Active Living Research
DISCLAIMER
Although this document has been prepared with due care and in good faith, the interpretations and opinions are those of the authors and are subject to change without notice. As such, the contents do not constitute definitive advice and should not be accepted as such. Neither ACA Employee Benefits (Pty) Ltd and Simeka Health (Pty) Ltd nor the authors accept liability for any damage whatsoever or however it may arise, including but not limited to, direct, indirect or consequential loss that may arise as a result of sole reliance on the information herein. Competent professional advice should be sought when dealing with any contentious issue. ACA Employee Benefits (Pty) Ltd and Simeka Health (Pty) Ltd is a duly authorised financial services provider.

 

 

Fedhealth Amalgamation with Topmed Medical SchemeFedhealth Amalgamation with Topmed Medical Schemehttp://www.sanlam.co.za/simekahealth/marketinsights/articles/Pages/fedhealth-amalgamation.aspxhttp://www.sanlam.co.za/simekahealth/marketinsights/PublishingImages/fedhealth_banner.jpg, /simekahealth/marketinsights/PublishingImages/fedhealth_banner.jpg4/30/2019 1:47:14 PM0168573aspx228http://www.sanlam.co.za/simekahealth/marketinsights/articles/Pages/Forms/AllItems.aspxhtmlFalseaspx2019-04-29T22:00:00ZTopmed members will automatically be defaulted into Fedhealth matching options.
Council of Medical Schemes propose amendments to 2019 Discovery Health contributions and benefitsCouncil of Medical Schemes propose amendments to 2019 Discovery Health contributions and benefitshttp://www.sanlam.co.za/simekahealth/marketinsights/articles/Pages/contributions-and-benefits-changes.aspxhttp://www.sanlam.co.za/simekahealth/marketinsights/PublishingImages/contributions_benefitsbanner.jpg, /simekahealth/marketinsights/PublishingImages/contributions_benefitsbanner.jpg12/11/2018 10:09:59 AM0126867aspx284http://www.sanlam.co.za/simekahealth/marketinsights/articles/Pages/Forms/AllItems.aspxhtmlFalseaspx2018-12-10T22:00:00ZFollowing the announcement of the 2019 Discovery Health Medical Scheme contribution increases and benefit changes, the Trustees have approved the following changes, as outlined in this post, for 2019.

 Most Read

 

 

Sanlam Life Insurance is a licensed financial service provider.
Copyright © Sanlam